Like that, most ideas posted here can quite easily be discarded as being at odds with the current game, or taking things too far away from it.
Many of the recent ideas, maybe.
But many of the ideas we've seen over the past 2-3 years have been quite good, I think.
I really wish that boating/sailing would be integrated into Eschalon. I don't even think it would be that difficult to implement (just make it basically a tiny sail boat, and if you encounter combat, the game could just automatically stand you up in the boat, and prevent you from sailing away...)
It's the one place I feel the Eschalon series has really failed to deliver, in comparison to, say, the Ultima series (or even Avernum). Lacking the freedom to just go sailing up and down the coasts is that one thing I felt was really lacking from Book I and Book II - that was one of the things I really loved about, say, Ultima IV.
I can definitely live without horse/steed-riding. But I'd really love to see proper boating in Book III.