The Drunken Lizard Pub

My first RPG was Phantasie 1 on my Atari 520 ST, sometime around 1986. Now that was a great game. Party-based with many races and classes, dungeons to explore, and turn-based combat. Graphics were pretty good too, for the time. (Most ST games had good graphics.)

After beating it I still had a lot ...

Looks like a mod of Dungeon Master Java?

A few art pieces in the screenshots were lifted directly, and the gameplay looks pretty much the same. DMJ is open source and freeware, so this is perfectly OK to do. It does seem like this should have been mentioned somewhere though.

Here's a few I've played myself:

Neverwinter Nights 1 and expansions
- great, lots of player-made modules

Baldur's Gate 2 + Throne of Bhaal
- great

Icewind Dale
- good, emphasis on combat

Fate
- fun little action rpg, gameplay similar to Diablo

Dungeon Master Java
- 1st-person dungeon ...