Page 1 of 3
Witch's house chest puzzle
Posted: February 23rd, 2014, 12:55 am
by mrnobodie
For the life of me I cannot figure it out & it's doing my head in. The potrait behind it has a 5 with a red border. What do I need to put into this chest?
Re: Witch's house chest puzzle
Posted: February 23rd, 2014, 1:14 am
by Ssschah
- [+] SPOILER
- The 5 represents 5.0lb (pounds) worth of items. They can be any items as long as they sum to 5.
Re: Witch's house chest puzzle
Posted: February 23rd, 2014, 1:23 am
by mrnobodie
Well, that's deceptively simple. I never would of figured that out. Whoever came up with that needs a pat on the back & a punch in the nose.
Re: Witch's house chest puzzle
Posted: February 23rd, 2014, 3:09 am
by SharpXe
this is standart weight sign from IRL.
use water skin (it can be set to 5 easy)
Re: Witch's house chest puzzle
Posted: February 23rd, 2014, 3:38 am
by mbrowne
SharpXe wrote:this is standart weight sign from IRL.
use water skin (it can be set to 5 easy)
Where in real life is that a standard weight sign?
Re: Witch's house chest puzzle
Posted: February 23rd, 2014, 5:48 am
by SharpXe
google ban only in extreme cases you know?
Re: Witch's house chest puzzle
Posted: February 23rd, 2014, 8:01 am
by hakea
I think that the best clue was in the description:
"You see a basic oak chest sitting upon some kind of floor plate"
- [+] SPOILER
- I often rush reading the captions, or miss them, so the first thing I tried was 5 red things (potion bottles). But - once I actually read the description again properly - the words "floor plate" immediately suggested some kind of pressure plate. I had no idea that the shape was supposed to be a weight symbol, but a deliberate weight seemed like a reasonably obvious thing to try on a pressure plate. Pleasantly surprised when it actually worked… Maybe it would be easier if it specifically said "pressure plate"?
Re: Witch's house chest puzzle
Posted: February 23rd, 2014, 11:51 am
by mbrowne
mbrowne wrote:SharpXe wrote:this is standart weight sign from IRL.
use water skin (it can be set to 5 easy)
Where in real life is that a standard weight sign?
SharpXe wrote:google ban only in extreme cases you know?
No idea what that means. I was wondering if you are saying that the trapezoid outline around the "5" is a weight sign somewhere in real life?
Re: Witch's house chest puzzle
Posted: February 23rd, 2014, 12:34 pm
by IJBall
mrnobodie wrote:For the life of me I cannot figure it out & it's doing my head in. The potrait behind it has a 5 with a red border. What do I need to put into this chest?
A few of us think this one might be a tad unfair/too hard - see
here (forward - look for "Raiders of the Lost Ark"...).
If this were on a side-quest, not crucial to completing the game, I think it would be totally fair, and I'd leave it.
But considering that it's crucial to the main quest-line, and most of us are
completely missing how to approach it, I think the clue either needs to be made clearer, or there needs to be a 'workaround' (e.g. by powder keg) put in there...
Re: Witch's house chest puzzle
Posted: February 23rd, 2014, 2:33 pm
by Eddy
hakea wrote:I think that the best clue was in the description:
"You see a basic oak chest sitting upon some kind of floor plate"
- [+] SPOILER
- I often rush reading the captions, or miss them, so the first thing I tried was 5 red things (potion bottles). But - once I actually read the description again properly - the words "floor plate" immediately suggested some kind of pressure plate. I had no idea that the shape was supposed to be a weight symbol, but a deliberate weight seemed like a reasonably obvious thing to try on a pressure plate. Pleasantly surprised when it actually worked… Maybe it would be easier if it specifically said "pressure plate"?
I didn't catch that.

This was the other riddle I needed help on.
I agree that should have lead me to the answer - the problem is I wasn't paying attention. I too tried quantity of items first.
I don't think the trapezoid is any kind of symbol for weight unless it has that circle above it like this:

Re: Witch's house chest puzzle
Posted: February 23rd, 2014, 2:34 pm
by IJBall
Eddy wrote:I don't think the trapezoid is any kind of symbol for weight unless it has that circle above it like this:

+1
That was basically my point in the other thread I linked to...
Re: Witch's house chest puzzle
Posted: February 23rd, 2014, 2:36 pm
by Eddy
The "floor plate" was a pretty good clue. I did miss it though.
I don't mind a real head scratcher or ten in a game like this. I really like the puzzles.
Re: Witch's house chest puzzle
Posted: February 23rd, 2014, 2:38 pm
by IJBall
Eddy wrote:I don't mind a real head scratcher or ten in a game like this. I really like the puzzles.
I don't mind it either, as long as the really hard or vague ones are not on the main quest-line - the problem was that this one
was on the main quest-line...
Re: Witch's house chest puzzle
Posted: February 23rd, 2014, 2:43 pm
by Eddy
IJBall wrote:Eddy wrote:I don't mind a real head scratcher or ten in a game like this. I really like the puzzles.
I don't mind it either, as long as the really hard or vague ones are not on the main quest-line - the problem was that this one
was on the main quest-line...
I hear your point. IMO it wasn't "too hard" for a main story line puzzle. Certainly a tricky one. But not that ridiculous IMO.
Obviously others may disagree.
Re: Witch's house chest puzzle
Posted: February 23rd, 2014, 4:43 pm
by HALgamer
Now that I put 5 pounds in the chest nothing happens. What does this do? I've searched all around the area and can't find what it opened or did.