Page 1 of 2
Favorite RPG setting
Posted: June 15th, 2007, 12:01 pm
by Metatron
Just a poll to keep you busy while the game is in development
I am curious to see the type of settings people prefer. In my opinion, setting is very important for any crpg (or any rpg for that matter). Unique settings provide memorable game experiences and good immersion into the game world. The trick is to create a game world that is not completely cliché or overdone while maintaining a level of familiarity with the audience. It seems to me that a game with a totally off-the wall setting may not succeed quite as well commercially as a sword-and-sorcery style high fantasy or medieval game.
What setting do you prefer? Are there any settings that you would like to see in a RPG in the future? Are there any settings that you consider to be completely terrible?
Posted: June 15th, 2007, 12:15 pm
by Gallifrey
Setting doesn't matter that much to me, I'm more interested in the story, gameplay and how the chosen setting is brought to life.
That said, a setting has to be something I am at least interested in, or I won't get a lot of enjoyment out of a title. I do thoroughly love when a game takes me on a travel to different locations or environments (so games like the Deux Ex, Tomb Raider and No One Lives Forever series are great, though perhaps not truly RPGs).
Out of your options, I like them all. Heck, mix them up a bit even. A cyberpunk Middle East campaign, a post-apoc Rome or a steampunk wild west.
I would, however, dearly love a good Cyberpunk 2020 RPG. Not an action shooter like that new Shadowrun game, but a good, solid, in-depth RPG using a faithful rendering of the 2020 rule set.
Posted: June 15th, 2007, 12:18 pm
by Gothmog
Voted for the Sci-Fi setting.
One of the best RPGs i´ve ever played was System-Shock and System-Shock 2. The athmosphere and story in this two classics is absolutley awesome! Im a great Sci-Fi Fan. Unfortunately there a way too few good Sci-Fi RPGs out there.
Last year the RPG-Codex brought an article about Laidback-Gaming. A indi game-developer making aturn-based SciFi-Game. Here is the link of their HP:
www.laidback-gaming.com
But since then, there are no news about "Dropship". I hope they are in deep-developing mode!!

Posted: June 15th, 2007, 12:23 pm
by BasiliskWrangler
I am partial to classical fantasy, more Tolkien-esque than "hyper-fantastical fantasy".
Modern/real-world or even historical doesn't always provide me with enough escapism. I prefer my role-playing definitely have an edge of imagination to it: magic, monsters, mutants, etc.
Anything else is fine as long as it feels like true role-playing and not just an adventure game with role-playing elements.
Posted: June 15th, 2007, 2:00 pm
by Dragonlady
I voted classic fantasy but would like to see oriental and other cultures, perhaps Arabic, or Africa or even India or American Indian.
Posted: June 16th, 2007, 5:09 pm
by MarionDeputy
I voted for sci-fi just because there haven't been that many good ones. Although you might not call it a true RPG, I have played more hours of X-com than any other game I own. I still play it to this day. So many developers have tried to re-hash the brilliance of the original and they have all failed. Someone could make a lot of money re-doing this game well. It still has a huge following.
Posted: June 16th, 2007, 5:14 pm
by Fleisch
I have played more hours of X-com than any other game I own. I still play it to this day. So many developers have tried to re-hash the brilliance of the original and they have all failed. Someone could make a lot of money re-doing this game well. It still has a huge following.
I agree, and I think some follow-on efforts missed the point by going real-time (and thus reflex-dependent). I'd love to see
the original X-Com with updated graphics. Isn't that what UFO-Extraterrestrials was supposed to be? Have you heard anything about how that turned out?
Posted: August 5th, 2007, 9:18 pm
by Grumolch
I voted fantasy/medieval, though I did pause to think about what I'd like to see. Maybe something a little different.
I've always been fascinated by Aztec and Mayan cultures. I think a setting like this, mixed with the magic of old-school fantasy, might be pretty cool. I've only seen these cultures represented in Age of Empires, but I've never seen an RPG with this backdrop. Blowgun of Yellow Fever +5! Woot!
Also pondering a different type of environment. Something colorful. I recall reading some Piers Anthony novels; I think one title was 'Magic Kingdom For Sale: Sold'; where there were trees called Bonnie Blues, that had bright blue foliage, and the main character's castle was actually a living entity.
Don't get me wrong. I like plain old pretzels. But I don't mind chocolate covered pretzels every once and awhile.
Gary
Posted: September 18th, 2007, 12:15 pm
by tormy
Forgotten Realms to be more specific.

Posted: September 18th, 2007, 1:09 pm
by Azarr
I like fantasy and there's nothing wrong with sci-fi, however I prefer Post Apocalyptic.
Posted: September 18th, 2007, 1:58 pm
by Fleisch
If I could go back and change my vote now, I'd vote for Wild West. I'd like to see one.
Posted: September 19th, 2007, 2:39 am
by gragnak
Gallifrey wrote:Setting doesn't matter that much to me, I'm more interested in the story, gameplay and how the chosen setting is brought to life.
That said, a setting has to be something I am at least interested in, or I won't get a lot of enjoyment out of a title. I do thoroughly love when a game takes me on a travel to different locations or environments (so games like the Deux Ex, Tomb Raider and No One Lives Forever series are great, though perhaps not truly RPGs).
Out of your options, I like them all. Heck, mix them up a bit even. A cyberpunk Middle East campaign, a post-apoc Rome or a steampunk wild west.
I would, however, dearly love a good Cyberpunk 2020 RPG. Not an action shooter like that new Shadowrun game, but a good, solid, in-depth RPG using a faithful rendering of the 2020 rule set.
I agree!
I played the pen and paper game.
I liked it very much.
About Shadowrun pc game..... no comment
Voted Fantasy classical.... the Star Trail serie was in my mind.
Posted: September 19th, 2007, 2:47 pm
by Fleisch
Yarrrr, it's talk like a pirate day! There should be a pirate RPG!
Posted: September 19th, 2007, 4:35 pm
by Baelthazar
Yo Mates! I have to be a sayin' that I prefer Post-Apocalyptic settin's... Post Apocalyptic Cthulhu settin's...
Bael
Posted: September 20th, 2007, 11:21 am
by Rollor
voted western.. A western rpg will surely rock hard
